Notifications
Clear all

Task for Roam

6 Posts
4 Users
10 Reactions
840 Views
Sky
 Sky
(@sky)
4-Star Recruit
Joined: 8 years ago
Posts: 1741
Topic starter  

Roam certainly is a knowledgeable fellow and does a good job backing up his positions with facts. I think he would enjoy jumping all over my request. 

I would like Roam to determine the impact of players opting out on the outcome of games. Who knows? Maybe when it is all said and done, players opting out has minimal impact. 

 



   
Quote
(@psujoe)
5-Star Recruit
Joined: 6 years ago
Posts: 4022
 

What???? How could you possibly be able to prove that one way or the other?  Compare it to Clifford getting injured in the Iowa game. We like to think we'd win that game if he played the entirety but there's no possible way of proving it.

 

Prog

 



   
Been There II, roaminglion, Been There II and 1 people reacted
ReplyQuote
Sky
 Sky
(@sky)
4-Star Recruit
Joined: 8 years ago
Posts: 1741
Topic starter  
Posted by: @psujoe

What???? How could you possibly be able to prove that one way or the other?  Compare it to Clifford getting injured in the Iowa game. We like to think we'd win that game if he played the entirety but there's no possible way of proving it.

 

Prog

 

Statisticians love this stuff. I’m curious if the data could should statistical relevance. I’ve suggested Roam tackle this because when it comes to knowing the facts, he is a walking encyclopedia.   Of course, even if the data demonstrated a connection, it doesn’t mean there was. 



   
ReplyQuote



(@been-there-ii)
5-Star Recruit
Joined: 8 years ago
Posts: 3569
 

Must be my little bit of scientific knowledge is derailed this morning. If they opt out, how exactly do you get data for them playing vs not playing? Sounds more like a spin doctor's dream, since it didn't happen, make up your own numbers!



   
PSUJoe and PSUJoe reacted
ReplyQuote
(@roaminglion)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 8 years ago
Posts: 9253
 

@been-there-ii I would start by taking the team's record and status for the year, W-L and likely odds going into the game. Then compare teams that had opt-outs to team that didn't have opt-outs. Were teams without opt-outs more successful during the bowl season on average?

Lots of math probably, and ultimately subjective depending on the factors I would decide to use or not. But generally speaking, it would be a comparison of the success rate for the control group (teams without opt-outs) vs. the success rate of teams with opt outs.

Interesting to see the results, but I ain't doing it. LMAO.



   
ReplyQuote
Sky
 Sky
(@sky)
4-Star Recruit
Joined: 8 years ago
Posts: 1741
Topic starter  
Posted by: @roaminglion

@been-there-ii I would start by taking the team's record and status for the year, W-L and likely odds going into the game. Then compare teams that had opt-outs to team that didn't have opt-outs. Were teams without opt-outs more successful during the bowl season on average?

Lots of math probably, and ultimately subjective depending on the factors I would decide to use or not. But generally speaking, it would be a comparison of the success rate for the control group (teams without opt-outs) vs. the success rate of teams with opt outs.

Interesting to see the results, but I ain't doing it. LMAO.

Just broke my heart Roam. 🙁

Hopefully ESPN will accept the challenge. 

 



   
ReplyQuote



Share: