Notifications
Clear all

Player Talent

30 Posts
8 Users
3 Reactions
336 Views
Tae Beutel
(@tae-buetel)
3-Star Recruit
Joined: 8 years ago
Posts: 481
Topic starter   [#8340]

Player talent is paramount, that's why unranked UCF, with a backup quarterback, beat #2 BYU, unranked South Carolina beat #11 Tennessee, unranked Cincinnati beat #8 Texas Tech, and unranked Minnesota beat #15 Iowa .......... or maybe not.

(Author's note: I'm just a casual observer of the human dynamic and amateur philosopher)



   
Quote
(@roaminglion)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 9625
 

Exceptions happen, doesn't make it the rule. Those teams that pulled upsets also lost some horrible games too.



   
ReplyQuote
(@southern-psu-fan)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 14174
 

I believe it’s fair to say a lot of our talent from last year went to VT and Tennessee because most of ‘em wasn’t wanted. The Iowa St players were the priority per MC. 



   
ReplyQuote



(@southern-psu-fan)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 14174
 

Penn State goes into Ohio and beat the Buckeyes to land 2027 running back Jordan Hall

Here is the RB I posted earlier I didn’t know his name at the time. I copied this.



   
ReplyQuote
(@roaminglion)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 9625
 

Posted by: @southern-psu-fan
↑

I believe it’s fair to say a lot of our talent from last year went to VT and Tennessee because most of ‘em wasn’t wanted. The Iowa St players were the priority per MC. 

"Wasn't wanted"

Yeah... most of the offensive players who left went with Franklin and the defensive players went with Knowles.

But sure... those coaches being at the exact schools the players ended up at was just an incredible coincidence 

 


This post was modified 4 weeks ago by roaminglion

   
ReplyQuote
(@southern-psu-fan)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 14174
 

@roaminglion MC used the word prioritized with his QB’s and Amare Cambell used the word disrespectful on the money he was offered that’s what we know for sure the rest is speculation but if MC did that to the 2 best players what makes you think he didn’t do the other players the same way when he brought 30 of his players with him?



   
ReplyQuote



(@roaminglion)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 9625
 

Posted by: @southern-psu-fan
↑

@roaminglion MC used the word prioritized with his QB’s and Amare Cambell used the word disrespectful on the money he was offered that’s what we know for sure the rest is speculation but if MC did that to the 2 best players what makes you think he didn’t do the other players the same way when he brought 30 of his players with him?

LOL

 



   
ReplyQuote
(@roaminglion)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 9625
 

Posted by: @southern-psu-fan
↑

@roaminglion MC used the word prioritized with his QB’s and Amare Cambell used the word disrespectful on the money he was offered that’s what we know for sure the rest is speculation but if MC did that to the 2 best players what makes you think he didn’t do the other players the same way when he brought 30 of his players with him?

Grunkmeyer, as well has his family have publicly stated his transfer was a mutual/personal career choice rather than a case of Campbell or Penn State actively rejecting or forcing him out.

But sure, go with whatever you want. Even when the kid and his family have said MC never said he didn’t want him, or that he had no chance to be the starter.

I mean... what was Campbell supposed to wait around and not get a QB in the portal while Grunkmeyer decided to leave? He entered the portal before Becht came to PSU... what's he supposed to do just hope the QB in the portal doesnt leave LMAO

 


This post was modified 4 weeks ago by roaminglion

   
ReplyQuote
(@southern-psu-fan)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 14174
 

@roaminglion MC said he was prioritizing his QB’s so what is Grunk supposed to do?



   
ReplyQuote



(@roaminglion)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 9625
 

Posted by: @southern-psu-fan
↑

@roaminglion MC said he was prioritizing his QB’s so what is Grunk supposed to do?

When? Show me when he said that before Grunkenmeyer left

 



   
ReplyQuote
(@roaminglion)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 9625
 

Posted by: @southern-psu-fan
↑

@roaminglion MC said he was prioritizing his QB’s so what is Grunk supposed to do?

You're so blinded and need to blame Campbell for not keeping Grunkmeyer that you are just completely disregarding what Grunk actually stated were his reasons for leaving. Publicly on Brenneman's podcast.

He didn’t feel pushed out, he felt that Campbell would give him a fair shot, but that it was best for his immediate and long term career to follow Franklin to Virginia Tech. And it was a very hard decision for him.

But I guess what does he know, it's just his life.

 


This post was modified 4 weeks ago by roaminglion

   
ReplyQuote
Tae Beutel
(@tae-buetel)
3-Star Recruit
Joined: 8 years ago
Posts: 481
Topic starter  

Later in the day, unranked Wisconsin, with only 200 yards of offense, beat #16 USC.  Notably, Wisconsin used an attacking defense that limited USC to 258 passing yards and -17 yards on the ground.  

 

Gee, seems as if letting a quarterback sit in the pocket and allowing running backs to get through the line unchallenged are not good ideas.  Maybe something has been learned, but probably not.



   
ReplyQuote



(@psu61)
4-Star Recruit
Joined: 8 years ago
Posts: 1318
 

Posted by: @tae-buetel
↑

Later in the day, unranked Wisconsin, with only 200 yards of offense, beat #16 USC.  Notably, Wisconsin used an attacking defense that limited USC to 258 passing yards and -17 yards on the ground.  

 

^ -17 rushing yards, didn't know that! 

 

 



   
ReplyQuote
(@roaminglion)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 9625
 

Posted by: @tae-buetel
↑

Later in the day, unranked Wisconsin, with only 200 yards of offense, beat #16 USC.  Notably, Wisconsin used an attacking defense that limited USC to 258 passing yards and -17 yards on the ground.  

 

Gee, seems as if letting a quarterback sit in the pocket and allowing running backs to get through the line unchallenged are not good ideas.  Maybe something has been learned, but probably not.

maybe Wiscinsin has good lineman, and we have a 8th year career vackup and a 5th year backup portal players starting. Could be a factor

 



   
ReplyQuote
(@psujoe)
5-Star Recruit
Joined: 6 years ago
Posts: 4335
 

We have serious talent issues pretty much all over the roster. A lot of poor personnel decisions were made.



   
ReplyQuote



(@psu61)
4-Star Recruit
Joined: 8 years ago
Posts: 1318
 

Posted by: @roaminglion
↑

maybe Wiscinsin has good lineman, and we have a 8th year career vackup and a 5th year backup portal players starting. Could be a factor

Yep. Bottom line is you cannot win on a consistent basis without talent, and I'll stick with my earlier comments about line play; you have to have a solid line on O and D, that is the foundation; build that and keep it refreshed, and a lot of other problems start getting fixed. No Qb wants to take a beating because of piss poor line play, and no LB wants to take an ass kicking from the O'line who is eating him for desert after blowing through the D'line as the main meal. 

Go back and look at a lot of Saqoun's runs that just died at or behind the line of scrimmage when O'line play sucked, nobody but Barry Sanders has ever been productive behind a shit line. 

 


This post was modified 4 weeks ago 3 times by PSU61

   
ReplyQuote
(@psujoe)
5-Star Recruit
Joined: 6 years ago
Posts: 4335
 

Posted by: @psu61
↑

Posted by: @roaminglion
↑

maybe Wiscinsin has good lineman, and we have a 8th year career vackup and a 5th year backup portal players starting. Could be a factor

Yep. Bottom line is you cannot win on a consistent basis without talent, and I'll stick with my earlier comments about line play; you have to have a solid line on O and D, that is the foundation; build that and keep it refreshed, and a lot of other problems start getting fixed. No Qb wants to take a beating because of piss poor line play, and no LB wants to take an ass kicking from the O'line who is eating him for desert after blowing through the D'line as the main meal. 

Go back and look at a lot of Saqoun's runs that just died at or behind the line of scrimmage when O'line play sucked, nobody but Barry Sanders has ever been productive behind a shit line. 

 

when one linebacker has more sacks than everyone on a defensive line combined you know you have a problem.

 



   
Underlion reacted
ReplyQuote
(@roaminglion)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 9625
 

One thing Miami has done is build a solid foundation on thr lines. Miami's OL and DL is very, very good. At that point, you're ahead of the game.



   
ReplyQuote



Underlion
(@underlion)
4-Star Recruit
Joined: 7 years ago
Posts: 1364
 

I posted this under the College Football.  

 

The guest is clearly more connected and smarter about college football than most of us.  He noted that the bowl game allowed the coaches that were leaving more weeks to recruit their players.  

Someone noted above that players went with coaches, either Franklin or the position coaches.  Terry managed to keep his guys to a degree.  I suspect we could have retained more but we'd have had to pay a premium over the premium they got to leave.

He suggests we are not going to be a top 10 NIL Money Team, we will have to recruit well as HS kids are a value for a year or two and we will have to develop/coach.

He credits Cignetti with being a good evaluator of talent.

Maybe our politicians will straighten it out with a salary cap or something.  The only constant is change.

https://www.youtube.com/live/lfYp5drrLKc?si=KlgIVIQwXyxw35dz

 



   
ReplyQuote
Underlion
(@underlion)
4-Star Recruit
Joined: 7 years ago
Posts: 1364
 

I think line play is where the NIL value is.  QB, edge rushers, RB's, Receivers get the big$$ but if you have to play Money Ball, and we do.  I'm betting spending $ on the lines is where it is at.

 

61 is right.  My concept would be to have a great offensive line and TE's,  Have running QB's that can throw and when one gets hurt replace him with another.

 

 

In 94 Kerry Collins got sacked less all year than some of our QB's have been sacked in a quarter....look it up.



   
ReplyQuote
(@psujoe)
5-Star Recruit
Joined: 6 years ago
Posts: 4335
 

@underlion 

It’s kinda hard to judge how bad the O line is when the QB seems to be afraid of getting hit and gets rid of the ball so quick. Looks like he has his mind made up where the ball is going before the snap.



   
ReplyQuote



Underlion
(@underlion)
4-Star Recruit
Joined: 7 years ago
Posts: 1364
 

I have watched him and and I have a hypothesis that he often takes the snap and looks to one side even though his primary receiver is on the other side.  I speculate it is just a habit and he doesn't intend to throw his first look a lot of the time because it is just a decoy look.  Now if it is a very quick pass he clearly throws his only look.  I propose he is not coming off his primary to a secondary, he just fakes a look opposite his primary.  

At first I thought he was surveying the field but I'm not sure anymore.  We have two good receivers, one hurt but it has been disappointing how rarely he checks down to a RB or TE.  And then the running OOB for a loss is bothersome.  He has had decent protection in some of these games but you may be right and he doesn't trust it.  For some reason he doesn't look like the most experienced D1 QB.  He looks average...which might be OK IF we had a running game.



   
ReplyQuote
(@the-funeral-director)
5-Star Recruit
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 2771
 

Posted by: @roaminglion
↑

Grunkmeyer, as well has his family have publicly stated his transfer was a mutual/personal career choice rather than a case of Campbell or Penn State actively rejecting or forcing him out.

Read that carefully...MUTUAL...In other words Penn State didn't want him...Career choice is saying I ain't sitting a year behind his boy when I can go someplace else and play right away...Trust me...If this coach wanted him and the school woulda paid him he would still be there...He was told he was bringing in his boy and Grunk said ok I am gone...That is how it went down...

 



   
ReplyQuote
(@roaminglion)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 9625
 

Posted by: @the-funeral-director
↑

Posted by: @roaminglion
↑

Grunkmeyer, as well has his family have publicly stated his transfer was a mutual/personal career choice rather than a case of Campbell or Penn State actively rejecting or forcing him out.

Read that carefully...MUTUAL...In other words Penn State didn't want him...Career choice is saying I ain't sitting a year behind his boy when I can go someplace else and play right away...Trust me...If this coach wanted him and the school woulda paid him he would still be there...He was told he was bringing in his boy and Grunk said ok I am gone...That is how it went down...

 

"In other words Penn state didn't want him"

LMAO it's like you want to read into one word so much so that you're willfully ignorant to the words that came after: "rather than a case of Campbell or Penn State actively rejecting him or forcing him out"

I mean... my lord. He litterally said Penn State didn't reject me or force me out, and you’re like "look ar the word mutual! He was rejected!!"

Then threw in a "trust me bro" for good measure.

 


This post was modified 4 weeks ago 2 times by roaminglion

   
ReplyQuote



(@southern-psu-fan)
Special Teams Coach
Joined: 9 years ago
Posts: 14174
 

Posted by: @psujoe
↑

We have serious talent issues pretty much all over the roster. A lot of poor personnel decisions were made.

Exactly the way I see it!



   
ReplyQuote
Page 1 / 2
Share: